【禁闻】官员财产公示难产 学者:自欺欺人

【禁闻】官员财产公示难产 学者:自欺欺人

【新唐人2011年6月27日讯】中纪委副书记吴玉良日前表示，中国当前要实践「官员财
产公示制度」条件还不成熟。为何被全世界公认为「阳光法案、终极反腐」的「官员财
产公开」，在中国却难产呢？学者认为，不是做不到，而是自欺欺人。

吴玉良在通报倡廉反腐的情况时表示，中国现在对官员的财产公示条件，因为「社会诚
信体系」和「资讯统计体系，这两个条件有欠缺，有关部门无法查询和统计，因此很难
发挥作用。

中国问题专家程晓农指出，上海市前几年要求公务员申报所拥有的住房，并声称只要申
报了就既往不究，显示中共并非掌握不了数据，而是不愿意做。

中国问题专家 程晓农: "实际上现在没有统计的原因是政府不愿意统计，结果他把没有
统计说成是不能监督的原因，如果政府真要监督的话， 其实很简单，政府拿出他维稳
的颈头，利用他维稳的系统，这些监控异议人士的手段， 如果用来监控官员 我不相信
查不出官员的财产。"

针对吴玉良声称官员财产公示欠缺条件，而回避官员财产公示的说法，香港《东方日报
》「神州观察」栏目评论指出：按照中纪委的说法，在中国推行「阳光法案」必须有条
件，但事实上这些条件在任何国家任何时候都可能欠缺，为什么世界上大多数国家和地
区包括像墨西哥、泰国等欠发达国家，都可以无条件实行反腐制度，唯独中国不可行
呢？

程晓农："只要他把身份证号全国统一的登记，那么很快的银行存款所有人的名字就查
清楚了，中国可以用身份证监控异议人士，说明他现在早就可以做到利用身份证监控他
想监控的人，所以从技术上来讲并没有任何困难。"

《东方日报》这篇《财产公示难产 官府自欺欺人》的评论文章认为，不就是因为社会
诚信荡然无存，官场贪腐无度吗?吴玉良声称「社会诚信体系」是官员财产公示的先决
条件，完全是本末倒置的逻辑，根本站不住脚。

而「所谓缺乏讯息统计体系，更不值一驳。推行「阳光法案」，只须建立一个数据
库，让官员自行申报，这对已经掌握卫星、高铁技术的中国来说，根本是轻而易举的
事。」

中国问题专家 程晓农:"他不愿意去监控官员，当然中国永远不具备对官员腐败的统计
或者监控。实际上政府各有关部门它们只关心一件事，怎么维护共产党的统治，怎么维
护官员的特权，当然它们就不愿意采取任何监控官员的手段。"

因此，程晓农认为，在中国「倡廉」这两字是假的。因为如果政府真的反腐的话，很容
易就可以根据现在的监控系统，把官员的财产、房子、存款查得一清二楚。

事实上，官员财产申报制度在内地已推行多年，但始终形同虚设，《东方日报》说，没
有一名贪官因为财产申报而丑行曝光，原因在于只申报不公示。

新唐人记者黄丽达,萧宇采访报导.

Property Discloser Refused

Wu Liangyu, deputy secretary of central disciplinarycommittee said, the
conditions for Chinese officialsto disclose their properties are
immature.Why the combating corruption property disclosurecan not be
implemented in China?Scholars think, it is the Chinese Communist Party(CCP)
that does not want to do it.

Wu Liangyu said, the two conditions, i.e., poor socialcreditability and
incomplete vital statistics in China,make it impossible for the officials
to disclosetheir properties and ineffective for the governmentto monitor
and check the information.

Cheng Xiaonong (China expert) said that Shanghai'authorities once required
government employeesto disclose houses they owned, with no punishment.This
indicates, it is not that the CCP can not do it,but rather that CCP does
not want to do it.

Cheng: "Lack of statistical data for implementingthe policy is because the
government does not wantto take the statistics. If the government really
wantsto do it, it is in fact very simple. Using the samedetermination for
maintaining social stabilityand the same resources for monitoring
dissidents,I do not believe it is impossibleto clearly investigate corrupt
officials' properties."

Hong Kong based Oriental Daily commented,Wu Liangyu indicates that it is
conditional for Chinato implement policy of officials' property
disclosure.However, no country in the world can haveperfect conditions
before implementing the policy.Then why most countries, including
developingones like Mexico and Thailand can implementthis policy
unconditionally, but China cannot?

Cheng: "With China's ID cards unified registration,the bank deposits'
owners can easily be checked out.The authorities are able to monitor the
dissidentsthrough their ID cards, meaning they can monitoranybody they want
using the ID cards.So, technically it is not difficult for the authorities."

Oriental Daily commented that it is due to the lackof social creditability
that makes corruption rampant.Wu Liangyu referred to social creditabilityas
a condition, which confuses the cause and effectand is just an excuse for
the government's inaction.

The lack of a statistical system claim is also nonsense.To implement the
policy, only a database is needed,where officials can report their
properties directly.This should not be difficult for China which
hastechnologies like the satellite and bullet train ones.

Cheng: "They are not willing to monitor the officials,of course China does
not have the related statistics.In fact, the regime is concerned with only
one thing,i.e., the stability of its rule and officials' privileges.This is
why they do not want to monitor officials."

Cheng thinks countering corruption in China is fake,because if the CCP was
serious, it could havealready used the current monitoring systemto
completely investigate the properties of officials.

In fact, CCP has promoted the property disclosurepolicy for many years with
no success at all.Oriental Daily said, not even one corrupt officialwas
exposed yet due to this policy,as CCP doesn't publicize it even if a
disclose is made.

NTD reporters Huang Lida and Xiao Yu 2011-06-27
10:51:44http://www.ntdtv.com/xtr/gb/2011/06/27/a551924.html.-【禁闻】官员财
产公示难产-学者:自欺欺人.html